There are 3 major reasons to purchase a Doughboy/CaliMar pool liner over a low-cost commodity liner:
1. Liner Thickness
Doughboy liners are typically 40%-80% heavier in both weight and thickness.
Doughboy liners have the same weight and thickness on both the sidewall and the bottom. Commodity liners typically have thicker, heavier sidewall than bottoms. Commodity liner manufacturers do this to reduce the price of the liner, but only advertise the sidewall thickness which can be misleading.
Doughboy liners are manufactured with heavier vinyl material and will last 50% to 95% longer than commodity liners.
Doughboy liners protect the sidewall and bottom of the liner from tears, rips, punctures, and holes caused by foreign objects in the soil, objects on clothing, windblown objects, lawn care debris, and entry system (ladders & step) contact on the bottoms and sidewalls.
2. Raw Material Make-Up
There are 3 major ingredients in the chemical makeup of a vinyl liner:
PVC (Poly Vinyl Chloride) is the main building block that goes into creating vinyl liners. PVC makes up 50%-60% of the total raw ingredients.
Plasticizer (petroleum-based oil) is another key ingredient that makes up 35%-40% of the total raw ingredients. This ingredient determines the flexibility of the liner and increases its chemical resistance and life span.
Inert Materials (calcium carbonate – a.k.a. clay) and Stabilizers make up 11%-30% of the total raw material ingredients.
Doughboy liners have increased levels of plasticizer and low levels of calcium carbonate. Typically raw material plasticizer costs are 4-5 times more per pound than calcium carbonate. Doughboy liners, with increased levels of plasticizer, will remain flexible during the life of the liner providing a wrinkle-free installation and minimizing UV fading. Commodity liners use a lower level of plasticizer (to save money) therefore compromising the quality of the liner.
3. Liner Life Span:
When comparing the purchase of Doughboy liners to commodity liners (calculated over the life span of the liner), Doughboy liners usually last 10-15 years. Commodity liners typically last 2-5 years. Both incur the same cost for installation, water and labor.
Why buy a Doughboy above ground pool liner instead of a low-cost commodity liner?
40%-80% heavier in both weight and thickness
Same weight and thickness on both the sidewall and the bottom
Made of a heavier vinyl material and will last 50%-90% longer
Protect the sidewall and bottom of the liner from tears, rips, punctures and holes
With higher levels of plasticizer, will remain flexible throughout the life of the liner, providing wrinkle-free installation and minimizing UV fading
Typically last 10-15 years
Doughboy liners are measured in mil, a true measurement. Don't be confused by the liner gauge "games" played with most commodity liners. Some will call their liner 20 gauge when they only measure 10 mil.
An 18' printed vinyl commodity liner like Swimline's Perma 2000 series liners weigh 41 lbs. and are marketed as 20 gauge and is closer to a 12 mil thickness, while the Doughboy 18' printed liner weighs 75 lbs and is a True 15 mil in thickness.
Swimlin's Perma 2500 series liners weigh 46 lbs and is marketed as a 25 gauge and is closer a 15 mil, while the Doughboy Expandable 18' printed vinyl liner weighs 84 lbs. and is a True 20 mil thickness.
Above ground pool liners are generally marketed and sold by thickness standard called gauge. Gauge is not a set number but is a truly relative number and is it's up to each of the liner manufacturers to determine which gauge they want to use for stating their liners' thickness.
truest measure of a pool liner is done using an international standard of mil thickness. This is an absolute fixed measuring system. Just like an inch is an inch, so to is a mil. Above ground pool liners because of the nature of the pools and their price generally do not have as thick a liner as an in ground pool. Therefore many of the above ground pool liner manufacturers started using gauge as a reference to their particular liners' thickness.
In the marketplace today there are really only two general gauges; standard gauge and heavy gauge. We offer pools with standard gauge and others with heavy gauge pool liners. Regardless of whether it's standard gauge or heavy gauge most above ground pool liners last anywhere between 8 and 15 years.
Our liners are made by the leading industry liner manufacturer and come with a 100% Lifetime Warranty against seam separation.
Our Standard Gauge is a more economical liner with acceptable thickness and wear considerations.
Our Heavy Gauge liners are the thickest above ground pool liners on the market today surpassing our standards for thickness and wear.
Our Calimar brand above ground pools which are manufactured by the same company who makes Doughboy pool and liners. These are the only liners in the marketplace with a True 15, 20 mil and 25 mil liner thickness. That's equivalent to an in ground pool liner thickness. Liners on CaliMar above ground pools come with a 100% Lifetime Warranty on seam separations, the most common failure point in liners.
Video Truth about Above Ground Pool Liners
The liners which come standard on all CaliMar above ground pools are Thicker, Better, Stronger and Last longer than any other above ground pool liner in the industry.